The Raven Saint by M.L. Tyndall, Charles Towne Belles, book 3 (Barbour, January 1, 2010), 320 pages
Earlier books in this series:
Book 1: The Red Siren
Book 2: The Blue Enchantress
Summary
Grace Westcott is driven. She’s determined to help the poor and needy in her community (Charles Towne), and save of her sisters, too. But when she’s kidnapped by a French mercenary and learns she’s to be sold to a wicked Spanish Don in Colombia, she doesn’t know what to think. She does get mad at God for putting her in this situation, though.
Thoughts
I don’t usually like reading a series out of order or a series book of any kind (beyond the first book) if I haven’t already read the previous installments. Something about the characters in this book caused me to make an exception in this case, though.
In a lot of ways, this wasn’t a book I would typically pick up — it’s a historical romance, set at least partially in the States. It’s a sea story. (I’ve read a few sea stories I enjoyed, namely Patrick O’Brian’s Aubrey and Maturin series, but for the most part I stay away from stories set on boats.) What drew me to this book, then? Grace Westcott’s strong drive to help the poor and save her sisters.
As a character, Grace was less than I hoped for. She fell into traps that are all too common in Christian fiction (albeit perhaps in actual Christians, too), and I quickly tired of her tirades and assumptions.
As a story, it was quite a bit better than I expected. It tackled some issues that aren’t broached enough, especially in Christian fiction.
The writing felt repetitive; the same characters were described over and over, with little change. Sometimes, a few pages after I learned something, I’d be told that same thing. I did enjoy the interspersing of French words and phrases throughout, even when I couldn’t understand all the words and they weren’t translated (which they were, most of the time).
I wish there was more white space on the pages. The interior pages feel quite crowded to me, between small margins and very little line spacing. This wasn’t as much of a problem once I really connected with the story.
All in all, some aspects of this book were pleasant surprises to me, while others were disappointing. This doesn’t normally happen to me, but I enjoyed reading the book, even though I didn’t like the main character most of the way through.
About the author
M.L (MaryLu) Tyndall has been writing for 20 years and lives in California. Her blog is Cross and Cutlass.
Other reviews
Have you reviewed this book? Leave me a link and I’ll add it here.
I received this book from the publisher.
4 comments
Comments feed for this article
January 26, 2010 at 11:10 am
April
Great review – very honest! This is a new book and author to me. I will have to check my library to see if they have the first in the series.
January 27, 2010 at 10:49 am
stacybuckeye
I read the first one and thought it was okay. And your review of this one reminds me why I didn’t continue with the series.
February 5, 2010 at 8:23 am
ibeeeg
I do not like repetitive information…it drives me crazy.
The layout of the book, the font, the space, the pages, etc. are a huge part of reading for me. I pleased to read your description of the overcrowded pages. Not too many people talk about the actual experience with the physical part of the book…myself included. While the overcrowded pages would bother me as well…deters from the story…it does not stop me from reading but is something I note…crazy huh? Sometimes, I think an author gets jipped a bit when stuff like that happens. Still, if the story is fabulous, the physical part of the book ranks low on my list.
Enjoyed reading your perspective on the book.
February 10, 2010 at 7:45 am
Words from my reading « Word Lily
[...] Review of the book cited here: The Raven Saint by M.L. Tyndall [...]